Blog · underwriting
Debt Yield vs DSCR: Which Limits Your Multifamily Loan?
Debt yield vs DSCR vs LTV for 5+ unit apartment loans: formulas, a worked $13.5M example, and how a 1% rate move changes which test limits your loan.
Send your 5+ unit deal
Five quick fields (phone optional). A multifamily specialist replies with a lender-fit read the same business day. No credit pull.
US 5+ unit multifamily only. We match deals to lenders; this site does not originate loans.
By Josh Bauerle · Reviewed by Scott Dillingham · Published · Updated · 9 min read
Short answer: debt yield (NOI ÷ loan), DSCR (NOI ÷ debt service), and LTV (loan ÷ value) are three separate tests, and your loan is the smallest amount that passes all of them. DSCR moves with interest rates, LTV moves with value, and debt yield ignores both. Run each one before you ask for quotes.
Multi-Family USA is a lender-matching service operated by LendCity America. We do not originate loans or set terms. This article explains how the math works so you can read a term sheet with confidence.
The three tests side by side
| Test | Formula | What it checks | Moves with |
|---|---|---|---|
| Debt yield | NOI ÷ loan | Leverage against income, with no rate or amortization assumption | NOI only |
| DSCR | NOI ÷ annual debt service | Whether income covers the payment | Rate, amortization, interest-only period |
| LTV | Loan ÷ value | Leverage against appraised value | Cap rate, appraisal |
Debt yield is the one that surprises sponsors. It has no interest rate in it, so a lender can use it to cap leverage no matter how cheap the debt looks. DSCR can be flattered by a low rate or an interest-only period. LTV can be flattered by an aggressive appraisal. Lenders use all three because each one covers the weakness of the others.
Which tests do the programs publish?
The official term sheets show how much the tests depend on the program:
| Program | Published tests | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Freddie Mac Optigo Conventional Small ($2M to $10M, generally) | 1.25x minimum amortizing DCR; max LTV 75% for 5 to under 7 year terms, 80% for 7-year and longer terms (65% to 70% for full-term interest-only) | Freddie Mac term sheet |
| Freddie Mac Optigo Fixed-Rate ($10M+) | Same 1.25x DCR and LTV grid | Freddie Mac term sheet |
| HUD 223(f), market-rate | 87% LTV and 1.15x DSCR | HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-03 |
| HUD 223(f), affordable with rent advantage | 90% LTV and 1.11x DSCR | HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-03 |
Notice what is missing: neither agency publishes a debt yield floor in these documents. HUD’s letter describes the maximum loan as the lesser of the requested amount, the statutory limit, the amount the DSCR supports, and the amount the loan-to-value ratio supports. Debt yield is usually a bank, debt fund, bridge, or CMBS screen, and each lender sets its own number. Treat any debt yield floor you see, including the ones in this article, as a lender-specific assumption.
Worked example: when a 1% rate move changes the answer
All numbers below are hypothetical round numbers for illustration, not a quote or a current market rate.
Assume a stabilized 60-unit property with normalized NOI of $1,000,000 and a value of $13,500,000. The lender screens use a 9.5% debt yield, 1.25x DSCR, and 75% LTV, with 30-year amortization.
Scenario A: 6.25% interest rate
| Test | Calculation | Maximum loan |
|---|---|---|
| Debt yield | $1,000,000 ÷ 9.5% | $10,526,000 |
| LTV | $13,500,000 × 75% | $10,125,000 |
| DSCR | $1,000,000 ÷ 1.25 = $800,000 of debt service ÷ 7.389% loan constant | $10,827,000 |
LTV binds at about $10.1M. The deal passes DSCR and debt yield with room to spare, so the only way to raise proceeds is a higher value.
Scenario B: 7.25% interest rate. The annual loan constant rises to 8.186%, so the DSCR test falls to $800,000 ÷ 8.186% = about $9,773,000. Now DSCR binds, about $350,000 below the LTV result, even though NOI, value, and the lender’s rules did not change.
That one point of rate cost roughly $1.05M of proceeds under the DSCR test. If you only modeled LTV at the start, you would be short at the closing table. Run the same scenario in the loan sizing calculator, then check one test at a time in the commercial DSCR calculator and the debt yield calculator.
When each test tends to bind
- DSCR binds when rates are high, amortization is short, or NOI is thin relative to price. It is the usual limit on stabilized agency deals in higher-rate markets.
- LTV binds when the purchase price runs ahead of income, or when a conservative appraisal comes in under contract price.
- Debt yield binds at lenders that screen on it. It is common on bridge, debt fund, bank, and CMBS execution, and it is the check that stops IO structures from stretching leverage.
For program-level detail, see Freddie Mac Optigo Conventional Small and the HUD 223(f) guide. Freddie Mac retired its Small Balance Loan on April 15, 2026, and Conventional Small replaced it, so older SBL grids no longer apply.
How to improve the binding test
- Find the binding test first. Fixing DSCR does nothing if LTV is the limit.
- For DSCR: lengthen amortization where allowed, reduce rate with a different program, or raise NOI by documented lease-up and expense cuts.
- For LTV: commission an appraisal that supports your assumptions, or add equity.
- For debt yield: only a higher normalized NOI or a smaller loan helps. Rate does not.
- Stress the result. Re-run at plus 100 basis points, as in Scenario B, before you commit to a price.
Rates move daily. Our multifamily loan rates page shows current index-based ranges by program. These are desk estimates, not lender quotes.
Common mistakes when comparing the three tests
- Sizing to the headline LTV. An advertised 75% to 80% maximum is a ceiling, not a forecast. Our example shows DSCR taking over after a one-point rate move, so treat LTV as the first test you check, not the last.
- Using pro forma NOI. Lenders underwrite their own normalized number, with their vacancy, management fee, and reserve assumptions. A sponsor NOI that is $50,000 higher than the lender’s can shrink the debt yield maximum by more than $500,000 at a 9.5% floor.
- Comparing quotes on different NOI. One lender sizing on trailing-3 and another on trailing-12 will give you different answers on the same building. Put every quote on the same basis before you compare proceeds.
- Ignoring the product. Interest-only periods, amortization length, and recourse change which test is tightest. A bridge lender and an agency lender can reach the same loan amount through different binding tests.
- Forgetting the exit. Freddie Mac’s term sheets waive their refinance test only at a 1.40x amortizing DCR and a 60% LTV or lower, which shows how much cushion permanent lenders want at maturity.
Next step
If you have a live 5+ unit deal and want to see which test limits it and which lender types fit that profile, send the numbers through our deal review. Multi-Family USA does not lend and does not pull credit on this form. For the full sizing framework, read the debt yield and LTV framework guide, and for lender-type floors see multifamily DSCR requirements by lender type.
Sources
- Freddie Mac, Optigo Conventional Small term sheet (April 2026).
- Freddie Mac, Optigo Fixed-Rate Loans term sheet (April 2026).
- HUD, Mortgagee Letter 2025-03, January 8, 2025.
This article is educational, not a loan offer or advice. Confirm terms with lenders and your own advisors.