Compare
FHA vs Agency Multifamily Loans — Which Fits Your Deal?
FHA/HUD 223(f) and 221(d)(4) vs Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae multifamily loans. Side-by-side leverage, DSCR, term, prepayment, recourse and timing, with a worked example and when each fits.
Send your 5+ unit deal
Five quick fields (phone optional). A multifamily specialist replies with a lender-fit read the same business day. No credit pull.
US 5+ unit multifamily only. We match deals to lenders; this site does not originate loans.
By Multi-Family USA Editorial Team · Reviewed by Scott Dillingham · Published · Updated · 11 min read
HUD/FHA and agency loans are the two main sources of long-term, fixed-rate, non-recourse debt on apartment buildings with five or more units. They differ in practice. This page compares them line by line so you can decide which to quote first, or whether to quote both.
Multi-Family USA is a matching service, not a lender. We do not make or fund loans. We route your property to lenders on the US desk, and nothing here is a quote or a commitment.
Quick answer
Choose HUD/FHA when you want the highest leverage and the longest fixed amortization, you can wait several months, and you can hold the loan past the 5-year prepayment bar. Choose agency when speed, a shorter and more flexible hold, and execution certainty matter more than the last few points of leverage. HUD 223(f) covers stabilized refinances and acquisitions, and 221(d)(4) covers new construction and substantial rehab. If the building is not yet stabilized, neither fits yet, and bridge or value-add debt usually comes first.
Side-by-side comparison
| Factor | HUD / FHA (223(f), 221(d)(4)) | Agency (Freddie Mac / Fannie Mae) |
|---|---|---|
| Loan size | Capped by the lesser of statutory limit, DSCR and LTV; minimums vary by lender | Freddie fixed-rate $10M minimum; Freddie Conventional Small generally $2M to $10M; Fannie Small Loan up to $9M |
| Leverage | Market-rate: 87% LTV or LTC under ML 2025-03; affordable: 90% | Freddie fixed-rate: 75% (5 to under 7 years), 80% (7 years and longer); interest-only 65% to 70% |
| DSCR floor | 1.15 market-rate; 1.11 affordable (ML 2025-03) | 1.25x minimum amortizing (Freddie fixed-rate); Fannie commonly 1.25x |
| Rate basis | Rate negotiated and locked by Initial Endorsement, plus HUD mortgage insurance premium | Fixed, priced off Treasuries plus a spread; early rate lock and Index Lock available |
| Term and amortization | Up to 35 years (223(f)) or 40 years (221(d)(4)), fully amortizing | Freddie fixed-rate 5 to 10 years, 30-year amortization; Fannie 5 to 30 years |
| Prepayment | 223(f): statutory 5-year bar from endorsement; lenders and notes may add schedules | Freddie: yield maintenance until securitized, 2-year lockout, then defeasance; no premium in final 90 days |
| Recourse | Non-recourse to the borrowing entity; “bad acts” carve-outs | Non-recourse except standard carve-outs |
| Timeline | Lender-reported roughly 4 to 6 months for 223(f); 221(d)(4) longer | Often two to three months; not officially published |
| Best fit | Long-hold, high-leverage stabilized refinances; new construction and substantial rehab | Standard stabilized apartments where speed and flexibility matter |
HUD figures come from HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-03 and the MAP Guide. Agency figures come from Freddie Mac’s April 2026 term sheets and the program pages linked below. Timelines are lender-reported or illustrative, not official. Confirm every number in a written quote.
How HUD/FHA loans work
HUD does not lend directly. Approved lenders originate the loan, and FHA insures it, which is how the program supports leverage and term that private markets rarely match. The two programs most investors meet are HUD 223(f), which refinances or acquires existing apartments, and HUD 221(d)(4), which finances new construction and substantial rehabilitation. See the overview at FHA/HUD multifamily loans.
Sizing is where HUD stands out. Under Mortgagee Letter 2025-03, issued January 8, 2025, market-rate 223(f) and 221(d)(4) loans moved to 87% LTV or LTC, up from 85%, with a 1.15 DSCR, down from 1.176. Affordable deals with rent advantage move to 90% and 1.11, and cash-out refinance LTV criteria did not change. The maximum loan is the lesser of the amount requested, the statutory limit, the DSCR-supported loan and the LTV-supported loan.
The MAP Guide fills in the rest. The rate is negotiated and locked by Initial Endorsement. Amortization is level monthly principal and interest only. The maximum term is the lesser of the statute, 40 years for new construction and substantial rehab, 35 years for 223(f), or 75% of remaining economic life. HUD charges a $3 per $1,000 application fee. For applications on or after October 1, 2025, the annual and upfront mortgage insurance premiums are each 0.25%; see the 223(f) page for the source. Recourse is limited to the mortgagor entity, with certain parties liable for bad acts under the Regulatory Agreement.
How agency loans work
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac do not lend to you directly. Approved lenders originate the loan and the agency buys it or guarantees it. Freddie Mac’s fixed-rate term sheet sets a $10 million minimum, 5 to 10 year terms, 30-year amortization and a 1.25x minimum amortizing DCR. Maximum LTV is 75% for terms from 5 to under 7 years and 80% for 7 years and longer. Prepayment is yield maintenance until securitization, then a 2-year lockout, then defeasance, with no premium in the final 90 days. The loan is non-recourse except for standard carve-outs.
Smaller balances run through other programs. Freddie’s Conventional Small program generally covers $2 million to $10 million, and Fannie Mae’s Small Loan program goes up to $9 million. See agency multifamily loans, Freddie Mac Optigo and Fannie Mae Small Loan. Fannie Mae figures here are the program-level numbers published in its DUS term sheets, so confirm them with a quote.
Choose HUD/FHA if
- You want the highest available leverage and the lowest DSCR floor on a stabilized apartment property.
- You plan to hold well beyond five years, so the 223(f) prepayment bar costs you nothing.
- Long, fully amortizing terms of 35 or 40 years help your cash flow more than flexibility does.
- You are building or substantially rehabbing and want a construction-to-permanent path under 221(d)(4).
- Your closing date is flexible, and you can carry the property for four to six months or more while HUD processes the file.
Choose agency if
- Speed matters, for example a purchase contract with a hard closing date.
- A sale or refinance is plausible within five to seven years, and you want a defined prepayment schedule rather than a statutory bar.
- You value an early rate lock and a lender relationship that handles supplemental loans, assumptions and reserves.
- The building is a standard, stabilized property and 80% leverage with a 1.25x floor meets your goal.
Worked example (hypothetical)
This uses round, made-up numbers. It is not a quote, a rate or a prediction. Assume the same stabilized 60-unit building used on our other comparison pages, with lender-underwritten NOI of $780,000 and an appraised value of $12,000,000. For illustration only, assume a 6.00% note rate on both loans, a 35-year amortization for HUD and a 30-year amortization for agency. Add the 0.25% annual mortgage insurance premium to HUD. That gives an annual loan constant of about 7.09% for HUD (6.84% plus 0.25%) and about 7.19% for agency. Real quotes will price differently, and HUD underwrites its own vacancy factor. Current index data is on our rates page.
| Constraint | HUD 223(f) (87% LTV, 1.15 DSCR) | Agency (80% LTV, 1.25x DSCR) |
|---|---|---|
| Max loan at LTV | $10,440,000 | $9,600,000 |
| Max loan at DSCR | about $9,560,000 | about $8,680,000 |
| Binding limit | DSCR | DSCR |
| Loan amount | about $9,560,000 | about $8,680,000 |
| Annual debt service | about $678,000 | about $624,000 |
| Actual DSCR | 1.15 | 1.25x |
| LTV | about 80% | about 72% |
| Cash flow after debt service | about $102,000 | about $156,000 |
The HUD loan returns roughly $880,000 more in proceeds because its DSCR floor is lower and its term is longer. It also carries about $54,000 more in annual debt service, so first-year cash flow after debt service is lower. On the HUD loan, the application fee of $3 per $1,000 comes to about $28,700, and the 0.25% upfront premium is about $23,900. At this size the agency leg would normally run through a small-loan program because Freddie’s fixed-rate minimum is $10 million, so treat the agency column as the fixed-rate grid applied for comparison only. Run your own numbers with the loan sizing calculator and the commercial DSCR calculator. Notice that DSCR binds on both loans, not LTV. That is why comparing headline leverage alone misleads.
Prepayment and hold period
The HUD advantage is tied to a longer hold. On 223(f) loans, the MAP Guide describes a statutory 5-year prepayment bar from endorsement, with limited exceptions. Other HUD sections impose no HUD restriction, but lenders and notes may add schedules. Freddie Mac’s fixed-rate loans use yield maintenance, a 2-year lockout and then defeasance. If a sale or refinance is plausible within five to seven years, price the exit with the yield maintenance calculator before choosing. A long HUD term with a low rate can still cost more if you leave early.
Timeline and execution
Agency loans generally close faster, and Freddie Mac fixed-rate loans can lock a rate early, typically 60 to 120 days out. HUD publishes no timeline. Lenders commonly report roughly 4 to 6 months for 223(f), with 221(d)(4) running longer because of plans, cost review and construction requirements. For a deeper look at HUD, read FHA and HUD multifamily financing. If the property is not stabilized, see agency vs bridge execution.
Related comparisons
- CMBS vs agency multifamily for the conduit alternative.
- Agency vs bridge if the property is not yet stabilized.
- Recourse vs non-recourse and fixed vs floating rate for the underlying structure choices.
Sources
- HUD, Mortgagee Letter 2025-03, January 8, 2025.
- HUD, Multifamily Accelerated Processing (MAP) Guide, March 2021.
- Freddie Mac Multifamily, Optigo Fixed-Rate Loans term sheet, April 2026.
- HUD, Multifamily programs.
Accessed October 8, 2026. Program terms change without notice, so confirm them in a current quote. Timeline figures are lender-reported or illustrative.
Get matched
Send us the property and the loan you want on the deal review page. We match it to HUD and agency lenders so you can compare real quotes side by side.
Agency vs bridge, bank vs debt fund, fixed vs floating — map the decision to your asset.