Compare
CMBS vs Agency Multifamily Loans: Leverage, DSCR & Prepay (2026)
When CMBS vs Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac fits 5+ unit apartments—side-by-side leverage, DSCR, prepayment, recourse and timing, plus a worked example.
Send your 5+ unit deal
Five quick fields (phone optional). A multifamily specialist replies with a lender-fit read the same business day. No credit pull.
US 5+ unit multifamily only. We match deals to lenders; this site does not originate loans.
By Chris Micucci · Reviewed by Scott Dillingham · Published · Updated · 11 min read
CMBS and agency loans are the two main sources of long-term, fixed-rate, non-recourse debt on stabilized apartment buildings with five or more units. They look alike on a term sheet and behave differently after closing. This page compares them line by line so you can decide which to quote first, or whether to quote both.
Multi-Family USA is a matching service, not a lender. We do not make or fund loans. We route your property to lenders on the US desk, and nothing here is a quote or a commitment.
Quick answer
Choose agency when the property is a standard, stabilized apartment building and you want the highest published leverage with a DSCR floor you can plan around. Look hard at CMBS when the loan is larger than the agency sweet spot, the property or business plan does not fit agency boxes, or conduit pricing is tight that month. On a clean asset, run both and let the quotes decide.
Larger platforms weigh this choice often; see the institutional growth operator playbook.
Side-by-side comparison
| Factor | CMBS (conduit) | Agency (Fannie Mae / Freddie Mac) |
|---|---|---|
| Loan size | Varies by conduit; usually mid-seven figures and up | Freddie Optigo Conventional Small generally $2M to $10M; Freddie fixed-rate $10M minimum; Fannie Small Loan up to $9M |
| Leverage | Illustrative 55% to 70% LTV; no single published grid | Freddie fixed-rate: 75% (5 to under 7 years), 80% (7 years and longer); interest-only lower, 65% to 70% |
| DSCR floor | Set by each conduit; often near 1.25x to 1.35x on amortizing basis, plus a debt-yield floor | 1.25x minimum amortizing on Freddie fixed-rate; Fannie conventional commonly 1.25x |
| Rate basis | Fixed, priced off Treasuries or swaps plus a spread | Fixed, priced off Treasuries plus a spread; Freddie offers an Index Lock |
| Term and amortization | Usually 5 or 10 years, up to 30-year amortization, often with interest-only | Freddie fixed-rate 5 to 10 years, 30-year amortization; Fannie 5 to 30 years |
| Prepayment | Defeasance or yield maintenance, where the loan documents allow it | Freddie: yield maintenance until securitized, 2-year lockout, then defeasance; no premium in final 90 days |
| Recourse | Non-recourse with bad-act carve-outs | Non-recourse except standard carve-outs |
| After closing | Servicer and special servicer run it under pooling rules | Lender services under agency rules; supplemental loans possible |
| Timeline | Often two to three months; not officially published | Often two to three months; early rate lock available |
| Best fit | Larger loans, off-grid assets, tight conduit spreads | Standard stabilized apartments wanting maximum leverage and relationship servicing |
The agency figures come from Freddie Mac’s April 2026 term sheets and the program pages linked below. The CMBS column is illustrative because conduits publish no common grid. Confirm every number in a written quote.
How agency loans work
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac do not lend to you directly. Approved lenders originate the loan and the agency buys it or guarantees it. Freddie Mac’s published fixed-rate term sheet sets a $10 million minimum, 5 to 10 year terms, 30-year amortization, and a 1.25x minimum amortizing DCR. Maximum LTV is 75% for terms from 5 to under 7 years and 80% for 7 years and longer. Full-term interest-only loans are capped lower, at 65% to 70%.
Smaller balances go elsewhere. Freddie’s Optigo Conventional Small program generally covers $2 million to $10 million on mostly market-rate properties of 5 to 50 units, with 5, 7, 10, 12 or 15-year terms. It replaced Freddie’s older Small Balance Loan program in April 2026, so any article still describing SBL as current is out of date. For the full picture see Agency multifamily loans, Freddie Mac Optigo, Freddie Mac Conventional Small and Fannie Mae Small Loan.
Fannie Mae’s Delegated Underwriting and Servicing lenders sit between you and the agency. The Fannie Mae Multifamily Guide requires a Non-Recourse Guaranty from each Key Principal, meaning the person who controls or manages the borrower or the property.
How CMBS loans work
A conduit lender originates the loan, pools it with others, and sells the pool as bonds. After that, a servicer manages the loan on behalf of bondholders, and a special servicer takes over if it defaults. The CRE Finance Council publishes the Investor Reporting Package, a standard set of bond, loan and property reports used across CMBS deals. Its data dictionary tracks defeasance status for each loan as full, partial, none or not allowable, and defeasance is available only where the loan documents allow it.
What that means for you: the rules are written at closing and administered by a servicer with a duty to bondholders. Assumptions, releases and modifications follow the documents, not a relationship. That rigidity is the price of capital that can reach properties and loan sizes agency programs do not. See CMBS stabilized loans for the program page.
Choose CMBS if
- The loan is larger than your agency lenders will comfortably size, or the property sits outside agency eligibility.
- You want interest-only years and your debt yield is strong enough for a conduit to give them.
- You have a firm exit date and the defeasance cost is modeled and acceptable.
- Your quotes show conduit spreads beating agency pricing for your asset.
Choose agency if
- The building is a standard, stabilized apartment property with solid occupancy and a clean rent roll.
- You want the highest published leverage, up to 80% on longer terms.
- You value a lender you can call about supplemental loans, assumptions or reserves.
- Pricing certainty matters, and an early rate lock or Index Lock fits your closing date.
Worked example (hypothetical)
This uses round, made-up numbers. It is not a quote, a rate or a prediction. Assume a stabilized 60-unit building with lender-underwritten NOI of $780,000 and an appraised value of $12,000,000. To isolate the sizing rules, assume the same 6.00% rate and 30-year amortization on both loans, which is about a 7.19% annual loan constant. Real quotes will price differently. Current index data is on our rates page.
| Constraint | CMBS (illustrative 65% LTV, 1.30x DSCR, 9% debt yield) | Agency (80% LTV, 1.25x DSCR) |
|---|---|---|
| Max loan at LTV | $7,800,000 | $9,600,000 |
| Max loan at DSCR | $8,340,000 | $8,680,000 |
| Max loan at debt yield | $8,670,000 | Not applied here |
| Binding limit | LTV | DSCR |
| Loan amount | $7,800,000 | $8,680,000 |
| Annual debt service | about $561,000 | about $624,000 |
| Actual DSCR | about 1.39x | 1.25x |
| LTV | 65% | about 72% |
The agency loan returns roughly $880,000 more proceeds here, because its DSCR floor is lower and its LTV ceiling higher. The CMBS loan has a thicker cushion, 1.39x against 1.25x. If the CMBS lender offered a lower rate or interest-only years, that cushion could change the picture, so run the numbers with the commercial DSCR calculator, the loan sizing calculator and the debt yield calculator. Notice that the binding constraint differs. That is why comparing headline LTV alone misleads.
Prepayment and hold period
Both products are expensive to exit early. Freddie Mac’s fixed-rate sheet lists yield maintenance until securitization, a 2-year lockout, and defeasance after that, with no premium in the final 90 days. CMBS exits run through defeasance or yield maintenance under the documents. If a sale or refinance is plausible within five to seven years, price the exit with the yield maintenance calculator before choosing a term. A longer term with a lower rate can still cost more if you leave early.
Related comparisons
- FHA vs agency multifamily for government-insured alternatives.
- Agency vs bridge if the property is not yet stabilized.
- Fixed vs floating rate and recourse vs non-recourse for the underlying structure choices.
Sources
- Freddie Mac Multifamily, Optigo Fixed-Rate Loans term sheet, April 2026.
- Freddie Mac Multifamily, Optigo Conventional Small term sheet, April 2026.
- Fannie Mae, Multifamily Guide: Key Principal Guaranty Obligation.
- CRE Finance Council, Investor Reporting Package v8.4, published March 13, 2024.
Accessed October 8, 2026. Program terms change without notice, so confirm them in a current quote.
Get matched
Send us the property and the loan you want on the deal review page. We match it to agency and CMBS lenders so you can compare real quotes side by side.