Skip to content

Compare

Fannie Mae vs Freddie Mac Multifamily Loans

Fannie Mae DUS & Small Loan vs Freddie Mac Optigo Conventional & Conventional Small for 5+ unit apartments. Compare loan size, LTV, 1.25x DSCR, amortization, supplemental loans, prepayment penalties, and sponsor net worth/liquidity rules.

Send your 5+ unit deal

Five quick fields (phone optional). A multifamily specialist replies with a lender-fit read the same business day. No credit pull.

Have the NOI and occupancy handy? Use the full deal review

US 5+ unit multifamily only. We match deals to lenders; this site does not originate loans.

By · Reviewed by · Published · Updated · 13 min read

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are the two government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs) anchoring stabilized US commercial multifamily debt for 5+ unit apartments. Both offer non-recourse execution, up to 30-year amortization, and competitive Treasury-indexed pricing—yet their lender delegation models, small-balance cutoffs, prepayment mechanics, and supplemental rules produce meaningfully different proceeds and exit flexibility.

Multi-Family USA is an independent lender-matching service operated by LendCity America. We do not originate loans; we match 5+ unit sponsors to licensed DUS and Optigo lenders so you can compare live quotes side by side.

Quick answer

  • Choose Fannie Mae (DUS / Small Loan) when your loan is between $1 million and $2 million (below Freddie Mac’s Conventional Small floor), when you want yield maintenance without post-securitization lockout/defeasance, when you value direct lender delegation from origination through servicing, or when your asset needs a 5-to-30-year term or Green Rewards feature.
  • Choose Freddie Mac Optigo (Conventional / Conventional Small) when your loan is $2 million to $10 million (5–50 units) or $10 million+, when you want Index Lock to hedge Treasury movement before rate lock, when step-down prepayment on Conventional Small fits a shorter hold, or when Freddie’s 7-year+ 80% LTV / 1.25x supplemental grid unlocks more future equity.
  • Quote both whenever your deal qualifies. Both agencies share a $88 billion 2026 FHFA multifamily purchase cap per enterprise with a 50% mission-driven affordable housing requirement, so lender allocations and spreads shift throughout the year.

Side-by-side comparison: Fannie Mae vs Freddie Mac

Underwriting FactorFannie Mae (DUS & Small Loan)

Freddie Mac Optigo (Conventional & Conventional Small)

Lender Delivery Model

Delegated Underwriting and Servicing (DUS) lenders underwrite, close, service, and share credit losses (commonly 1/3 lender, 2/3 Fannie Mae pari passu).

Optigo seller/servicers originate and sell loans to Freddie Mac; conventional fixed-rate loans are typically securitized after closing.

Loan Size Range

Small Mortgage Loans: $9M or less (DUS lender floors often start near $1M). Core DUS: lender-specific minimums above $9M.

Optigo Conventional Small: generally $2M–$10M on 5–50 units (replaced SBL on April 15, 2026). Optigo Conventional fixed-rate: $10M minimum.

Maximum LTV

Up to 80% LTV on conventional stabilized and Small Loan term sheets (lower for cash-out or specific tiers).

75% LTV for 5 to <7-year terms; 80% LTV for 7+ year terms (amortizing or partial IO). Full-term IO capped at 65%–70% LTV.

Minimum DSCR

1.25x minimum on underwritten net cash flow (after ≥3% management fee and condition-rated reserves of $200–$300+/unit).

1.25x minimum amortizing DCR; interest-only periods are still tested on a 30-year amortizing payment.

Term & Amortization

5 to 30 year terms; amortization up to 30 years; fixed or variable (SOFR) rate structures.

Conventional: 5 to 10 years (up to 30 years if unsecuritized); Conventional Small: 5, 7, 10, 12, or 15 years; up to 30-year amortization. Partial IO requires ≥2 years amortization.

Prepayment Structure

Fixed-rate: yield maintenance with 3-month open window at maturity. Variable-rate: declining prepayment premium.

Conventional fixed: yield maintenance until securitized, 2-year lockout, then defeasance (final 90 days open). Conventional Small also offers step-down or YM without defeasance at added cost.

Supplemental Financing

Available 12 months post-close via existing servicer; combined LTV up to 75% / 1.30x DSCR; New Loan Test applies if ≤5 years remain on senior loan.

Available ≥12 months after prior loan ($1M minimum); unavailable in final 3 years; 75%/1.35x to 80%/1.25x combined grid; 70% combined maturity LTV cap.

Recourse & Entity

Non-recourse (typically >$750k) with standard bad-act carve-outs; Key Principal Non-Recourse Guaranty required.

Non-recourse with standard carve-outs; Single Purpose Entity (SPE) generally required (LP, corp, LLC, or ≤5 TICs on Conventional Small).

Net Worth & Liquidity Covenants

Small Loans (≤$9M): combined net worth ≥ loan amount; post-closing liquidity ≥ 9 months P&I (retirement & related-party notes excluded); credit checks ≤90 days from ≥2 bureaus.

Underwritten per Freddie Mac Seller/Servicer Guide and Optigo lender overlays (typically net worth ≥ loan amount and liquid reserves of 9–12 months debt service).

Rate Lock Mechanics

30- to 180-day commitments; Streamlined Rate Lock available through DUS lenders.

Early lock typically 60–120 days (60-day spread lock after application on Conventional Small); Index Lock available to lock Treasury early.

How Fannie Mae DUS & Small Loans work

Fannie Mae delegates credit underwriting, closing, and servicing directly to approved DUS lenders under a shared-risk model. Because the DUS lender retains a portion of credit loss (commonly one-third pari passu, or tiered loss-sharing capped at 20%), lender underwriting focuses heavily on trailing-12 collections, verified bank deposits, and realistic expense normalization.

Under Fannie Mae Multifamily Guide Section 905.01, lenders deduct a property management fee equal to the greatest of 3% of effective gross income, actual contractual management fees, or the appraiser’s concluded market fee—even on self-managed buildings. Replacement reserves are deducted by property condition rating ($200/unit for rating 1, $250/unit for rating 2, and $300/unit for rating 3).

For balances of $9 million or less, the Fannie Mae Small Loan path (Part III, Chapter 9, Section 901) streamlines third-party reports (including ASTM E-1528-14 environmental screening) while enforcing explicit sponsor tests: combined net worth at least equal to the loan amount and post-closing liquidity of at least 9 months of P&I, excluding retirement funds (IRAs/401(k)s) and related-party notes.

How Freddie Mac Optigo Conventional & Conventional Small work

Freddie Mac executes stabilized multifamily loans through its Optigo lender network. On April 15, 2026, Freddie Mac retired its standalone Small Balance Loan (SBL) platform and integrated small deals into its core Conventional framework as Optigo Conventional Small.

That 2026 structural shift matters for borrowers:

  1. Higher ceiling, higher floor. Old SBL stopped at $7.5 million and reached down to $1 million. Optigo Conventional Small raises the cap to $10 million (bridging cleanly up to the $10 million minimum of core Optigo Fixed-Rate Conventional), while moving the floor to generally $2 million on 5–50 predominantly market-rate units.
  2. Term-linked leverage grid. Freddie Mac caps amortizing and partial interest-only loans at 75% LTV on 5-to-under-7-year terms and 80% LTV on 7-year and longer terms, while requiring 1.25x minimum DCR calculated on an amortizing payment even during interest-only periods.
  3. Excluded small-loan collateral. Per Freddie Mac’s Conventional Small term sheet, student housing, seniors housing, manufactured housing communities, cooperatives, fractured condos, HAP contracts, and master/ground leases are excluded from Conventional Small (whereas core Optigo Conventional and Fannie Mae cover several of those specialized classes).

Prepayment, supplemental loans, and hold-period math

Headline coupons often look nearly identical across DUS and Optigo term sheets, yet exit economics and mid-hold equity access separate the two programs:

  • Yield maintenance vs lockout + defeasance: A standard fixed-rate Fannie Mae DUS loan uses yield maintenance throughout the term until the final 3 months. By contrast, a securitized Freddie Mac Optigo Conventional loan imposes yield maintenance until securitization, a 2-year hard lockout, and then defeasance until the final 90 days (though yield maintenance without defeasance or step-down options may be purchased on Conventional Small for a spread add-on). Model early exit costs in the yield maintenance calculator.
  • Supplemental timing and windows: Both agencies require 12 months of seasoning before adding a multifamily supplemental loan. Fannie Mae tests combined debt at up to 75% LTV / 1.30x DSCR and triggers a New Loan Test if 5 years or less remain on the senior maturity. Freddie Mac bans supplementals entirely during the final 3 years of the first mortgage and caps combined maturity LTV at 70%, but permits up to 80% combined LTV at 1.25x DCR when 7+ years remain.

Worked sizing example: $6.5M agency deal (hypothetical)

Assume a stabilized 48-unit garden-style apartment property appraised at $8,400,000 with lender-underwritten NOI of $540,000 (after management fee and reserves). Assume a 6.00% fixed coupon on a 7-year term with 30-year amortization (annual loan constant ~7.19%):

ConstraintFannie Mae Small Loan (80% LTV / 1.25x)Freddie Mac Conventional Small (7-Yr 80% LTV / 1.25x)
LTV Ceiling (80%)$6,720,000$6,720,000
DSCR Ceiling (1.25x)($540,000 / 1.25) / 7.19% ≈ $6,008,000($540,000 / 1.25) / 7.19% ≈ $6,008,000
Binding ConstraintDSCR at ~$6,008,000 (~71.5% LTV, 9.0% debt yield)DSCR at ~$6,008,000 (~71.5% LTV, 9.0% debt yield)
Required Post-Close Liquidity (9 mos P&I)~$324,000 (excludes retirement & related-party notes)Lender/Optigo guide reserve check (typically 9–12 mos P&I)
Early Exit at Year 4 (if rates drop)Yield maintenance on remaining balanceDefeasance (unless step-down option was priced at close)

Run your deal inputs through the loan sizing calculator, commercial DSCR calculator, and debt yield calculator before choosing between DUS and Optigo quotes.

2026 FHFA volume caps and lender appetite

Both Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac operate under annual multifamily purchase limits set by their federal regulator, the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA). On November 24, 2025, FHFA set the 2026 multifamily loan purchase caps at $88 billion each ($176 billion combined), required at least 50% of each enterprise’s volume to qualify as mission-driven affordable housing, and excluded workforce housing loans from the caps (FHFA 2026 Cap Release). Because market-rate deals compete for the capped half of each GSE’s book, one agency may widen or tighten spreads mid-year while the other stays aggressive—making dual quoting essential.

Sources

Next step

Submit your T-12, rent roll, and hold horizon on our deal review page. Our US desk routes 5+ unit scenarios to licensed DUS and Optigo lenders so you can evaluate real spreads, prepayment options, and proceeds side by side—with no credit pull.

Frequently asked questions

What is the core structural difference between Fannie Mae DUS and Freddie Mac Optigo?
Fannie Mae uses Delegated Underwriting and Servicing (DUS) lenders that underwrite, close, and service loans while sharing credit losses with Fannie Mae (commonly one-third lender / two-thirds Fannie Mae pari passu). Freddie Mac uses Optigo lenders that originate and sell loans to Freddie Mac under Optigo Conventional and Conventional Small product sheets, with most fixed-rate loans subsequently securitized.
How do Fannie Mae Small Loans and Freddie Mac Conventional Small compare on loan size?
Fannie Mae's Multifamily Guide defines a Small Mortgage Loan as $9 million or less, with DUS lenders often starting near $1 million. Freddie Mac integrated its Small Balance Loan (SBL) program into its Conventional platform on April 15, 2026 as Optigo Conventional Small, covering generally $2 million to $10 million on 5 to 50 units, while Optigo Conventional fixed-rate loans start at $10 million.
Do both Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac require a 1.25x DSCR and 80% max LTV?
Yes for standard stabilized conventional properties, though term and IO rules differ. Both commonly underwrite to a 1.25x minimum amortizing DSCR and up to 80% maximum LTV. Freddie Mac caps 5-to-under-7-year fixed-rate terms at 75% LTV and 7-year-plus terms at 80% LTV, with full-term interest-only capped at 65% to 70% LTV.
How do prepayment penalties differ between Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac?
Fixed-rate Fannie Mae DUS loans typically carry yield maintenance with a 3-month open window at maturity, while variable-rate loans use a declining prepayment schedule. Fixed-rate Freddie Mac Optigo Conventional loans carry yield maintenance until securitization, a 2-year lockout, and then defeasance with no premium in the final 90 days; Conventional Small offers step-down and yield-maintenance alternatives at additional cost.
Which agency is better for supplemental financing later?
Both allow supplemental loans 12 months after senior loan closing, tested on combined debt service and unpaid balance. Fannie Mae allows fixed or variable supplementals up to 75% combined LTV / 1.30x DSCR (with a New Loan Test if under 5 years remain on the senior loan). Freddie Mac requires a $1 million minimum, bars supplementals in the final 3 years of the first loan, and caps combined maturity LTV at 70%.
What net worth and liquidity covenants apply to agency multifamily borrowers?
For Fannie Mae Small Mortgage Loans ($9 million or less), Part III Chapter 9 of the Multifamily Guide requires combined borrower and key principal net worth at least equal to the loan amount and post-closing liquid assets of at least nine monthly P&I payments (generally excluding retirement accounts and related-party notes). Both agencies require Single Purpose Entity (SPE) governance and non-recourse carve-out guaranties on standard executions.
Related Resources A–Z

resources

Hand-picked next steps — go deeper, compare alternatives, or run the numbers.

Need Help Choosing the Capital Path?

Agency vs bridge, bank vs debt fund, fixed vs floating — map the decision to your asset.

Book a call Deal review